I’ve been thinking more about the riots in Sydney of late – in particular the roll of race in them.
It seems clear to me that racism was a factor in the riots and this is probably the most disturbing element of it. But was it really what caused them? It is to some extent but I can’t help but feel it would be foolish to limit our analysis to “they’re a bunch of racist dickheads”. No doubt they are, but that’s not the whole story.
Over at GetBlogged Lachlan says:
I have seen the pictures, read the text messages, and heard the commentary, but I am not buying these race riot claims. It’s not because I don’t believe Australia is a racist society. A quick read of the comments below will quickly establish that it is. And it’s not because I don’t think there is tension between different ethnic groups in Sydney, because the undeniable fact is, there is.
The reason I have rejected the description of the violence in Sydney as race riots is because it is a description that is too kind to the people who have taken part.
The young men who rampaged through Cronulla and Maroubra, and a few of the suburbs in between, were not interested in anything as abstract as their race. They were simply exercising their own capacity to hurt and destroy when there is no danger, and run and hide when there is.
That crowd in Cronulla on Sunday didn’t care about the Shire, or any of the people who live in it. They simply indulged themselves in a gratuitous orgy of mob violence for the simple reason that they could. They weren’t defending Australian values; they were defending the brittle skeleton of self-esteem that holds their vanilla flavoured existence together.
I think he has a point. There were skinheads involved but they might have been 100 at most of the 5000 strong crowd.
Kate over at Moment to Moment makes a similar point:
My reaction to this mess is mostly a mix of puzzlement and disgust. But beyond that, I wonder how much of this is really about ‘race’. Yeah yeah, the 5000 boofheads at the beach were chanting about “keeping the Lebbos out” — but if it weren’t the “Lebbos”, wouldn’t it be someone else?
I’m not denying there’s a problem with a subset of Lebanese young men who act like dickheads. But there seems to be quite a subset of Anglo young men who act like dickheads too, and all this seems less about race and racism and more about young men + time on their hands + booze and drugs = violence. Pissing wars between groups of young, angry blokes are nothing new, and the divisions can be as minor as which footy team you go for, to what country your grandparents came from.
There are non-violent, anti-racist rallies in Sydney and Melbourne this weekend (the Melbourne one is 5 pm Friday (16th) @ Bourke St Mall). I’ll be attending the Melbourne one as it is particularly important to publicly display my disgust at the riots and to send a clear message that Australians aren’t racist and join in solidarity with our brothers and sisters from around the world.
However, it is worthwhile considering the other factors involved in these acts.